2 Surprisingly strong growth in the euro area
The euro area economy expanded with surprising vigour in the first quarter of 2024. According to Eurostat’s flash estimate, euro area GDP increased by 0.3% in price and seasonally adjusted terms compared with the previous quarter, following a slight decline in the final quarter of 2023. This marked growth is likely to be mainly attributable to the improvement in economic activity in various services sectors and to the boost in the construction sector caused by favourable weather conditions. By contrast, the slowdown in manufacturing continued. In the current quarter, the underlying economic trend is likely to remain moderately upward. The burdens caused by the sharp price increases in recent years are diminishing further, and the global economy is providing a supportive stimulus. However, various hindering factors remain, in particular high geopolitical uncertainty and a tighter monetary policy stance.
The gradual recovery in private consumption continued in the first quarter. Real disposable income is likely to have increased markedly in light of the good labour market situation, the significant rise in wages and weaker inflation. This is likely to have been reflected more strongly in demand for services. In any case, sales in the hotel and restaurant sector increased markedly in January and February in price-adjusted terms. Consumption of goods also recovered. After several quarters of very weak dynamics, retail sales rose noticeably in price-adjusted terms. However, the number of new motor vehicle registrations declined once again. At the same time, consumer confidence remained below its long-term average, despite some improvement over the quarter. Overall, private consumption remained subdued.
The increase in investment was probably only temporary. 3 The fairly strong increase in construction output in January and February suggests an increase in construction investment in the first quarter. However, this is likely to be due to temporary effects, particularly public infrastructure measures and the exceptionally mild weather. Fundamentally, the situation in the construction sector remains difficult. According to surveys, construction orders continued to decline and the number of building permits for residential buildings also dropped markedly again until January. Investment in machinery and equipment probably went down again. Capital goods producers’ domestic sales decreased considerably in January and February after price adjustment. By contrast, investment in information and communication technologies and intellectual property is likely to have expanded further owing to the trend towards digitalisation.
Exports of goods to third countries probably increased significantly at the beginning of the year. Exports of intermediate and consumer goods rose in particular. Considered by country, exports to China, in particular, are likely to have recovered significantly, after having fallen sharply in the previous three quarters. Exports to the United States and the United Kingdom probably also increased markedly. According to balance of payments data, euro area services exports rose strongly until February, probably largely driven by buoyant tourism business. By contrast, imports of goods from third countries are likely to have declined in the first quarter, with broad weakness across product classes.
The slowdown in the manufacturing sector continued. Only intermediate goods production recovered somewhat after significant declines in previous quarters. By contrast, capital and consumer goods production fell. Motor vehicle production, in particular, was markedly lower than in the previous quarter. There were signs of bottoming out in particularly energy-dependent sectors such as the chemical industry. According to European Commission Business and Consumer Surveys, the weak industrial activity continued to be driven by a lack of demand. By contrast, shortages of materials and labour now appear to be far less relevant. Above and beyond that, price pressures at the producer level eased considerably. Producer and import prices fell significantly on the year, mainly owing to falling energy prices but also to declining prices for intermediate goods. Capacity utilisation fell further below its long-term average between January and April.
The services sector improved in the first quarter. Activities in the hotel and restaurant sector and among business-related service providers are likely to have increased markedly. In addition, the expansion of the information and communications sector appears to have intensified. According to European Commission surveys, however, labour shortages weighed on the services sector as a whole.
At the beginning of the year, growth in macroeconomic activity was broadly spread across Member States. This improvement in the economic situation was seen above all in those countries where the negative effects of the energy crisis, high inflation and Russia’s war on Ukraine had previously been particularly strong, including Germany. 4 Economic activity in the southern Member States, by contrast, remained relatively vigorous, supported by lively tourism and projects funded by the European Recovery Fund.
Economic output in France rose markedly at the beginning of the year. According to initial estimates, real GDP grew by 0.2% in the first quarter, following a slight increase in the previous quarter. Positive stimuli came from domestic demand. Private consumption rose markedly, especially in the services sector. Investment also expanded markedly after the weak second half of 2023. Exports remained buoyant. In addition to exports of goods, the favourable tourism business also played a role. Imports also increased again after their significant decline at the end of the year. On the output side, the growth boost was solely attributable to the services sector. By contrast, industrial output suffered a setback, and the construction sector again experienced a steep decline.
In Italy, macroeconomic activity increased markedly in the first quarter. According to provisional data, real GDP rose by 0.3%, following an increase of 0.1% in the final quarter of 2023. Exports were the main source of this increase. By contrast, domestic demand remained rather weak. Private consumption is likely to have fallen further, and investment appears to have increased only marginally despite buoyant construction activity. As a result, imports are also likely to have declined. On the output side, both industrial output and activity in the services sector picked up somewhat.
In Spain, the vigorous cyclical upswing continued. According to initial estimates, real GDP increased by a seasonally adjusted 0.7%, as in the previous quarter. Growth was driven by a further increase in consumer spending and a substantial increase in exports, particularly of services. Investment activity also increased markedly, especially in equipment and non-residential buildings. On the output side, activity in the manufacturing, construction and retail sectors increased significantly.
Growth in economic output was also quite strong in several smaller Member States. Real GDP rose again significantly in Portugal, Slovakia and Cyprus in particular. Economic output grew moderately in Belgium and Austria. Activity stagnated in the Netherlands and Slovenia. In Finland, Lithuania and Latvia, which had been particularly affected by the war in Ukraine, the economic situation improved. In Estonia, by contrast, the recession continued.
Euro area labour market conditions remained favourable in the first quarter of 2024. Unemployment held steady at its low of 6.5%, and the number of people in employment rose again very robustly. However, labour market tightness has decreased somewhat recently. According to a European Commission indicator, labour hoarding declined somewhat, 5 and employment expectations for the next three months diminished. The vacancy rate fell in line with the subdued economic activity. Wage growth is likely to have been comparatively high in the first quarter, too, at between 4% and 5% on the year.
Consumer price inflation strengthened again in the first quarter of 2024 in comparison to the last quarter of 2023. Inflation as measured by the Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (HICP) was 0.7% higher in seasonally adjusted terms on the quarter. This was mainly due to greater momentum in service prices, which are determined by wages in particular. However, prices for industrial goods (including energy) and processed food also continued to rise. Only prices for unprocessed food fell somewhat.
Headline inflation, measured as the annual change in the HICP, nevertheless declined. Non-energy industrial goods inflation, in particular, fell markedly from 2.9% in the last quarter of 2023 to 1.6% in the first quarter of 2024. By contrast, service and food price inflation remained significantly higher at 4%. Energy prices were still below their previous year’s level. However, the gap narrowed markedly. As a result, headline HICP fell further only slightly to 2.6%, compared with 2.7% in the previous quarter. The rate excluding energy and food fell more significantly, from 3.7% to 3.1%.
Inflation remained markedly elevated in April, too. In April, prices for almost all components rose more sharply in seasonally adjusted terms than in March. Only non-energy industrial goods prices decreased. This weakened the disinflation process somewhat. This was mainly due to the resurgence of energy prices and continued high wage growth. Annual HICP inflation persisted at 2.4%. While the core rate fell somewhat further from 2.9% to 2.7%, the increase in services prices remained markedly higher.
The underlying pace of the economic recovery in the euro area is likely to remain subdued for now. Part of the surprise growth seen in the first quarter is likely to be due to a temporary improvement in the construction sector. There could be a countermovement in this area in the second quarter. Sentiment indicators also do not yet indicate a significant strengthening of the underlying economic trend, and economic activity appears to remain divided. While, at least in some segments, services sector activity has been lively, industrial output remains weak. Production expectations in industry declined again in April, and order books were assessed less favourably. The outlook for the construction sector also remains extremely subdued given the strict financing conditions. The outlook for private consumption seems to be better. Consumer confidence rose up to April, with households noticeably feeling better about their financial situation, in particular. Tourism business, in particular, could benefit from this. Any marked strengthening of macroeconomic growth in the euro area would probably require the high level of uncertainty arising from geopolitical conflicts to first subside.